Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
People in struggling school districts aren’t disengaged. If anything, they’re trying to get involved but find themselves running into a wall.
That’s the finding of a new report from the Hoover Institution, based on its “Unheard Voices” project. Hoover researchers held nine in-person focus groups across seven states — Colorado, West Virginia, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, Indiana, New Mexico and New York — and talked with 82 participants, from parents and teachers to leaders of nonprofit organizations and elected officials. The format combined short surveys with open-ended discussions, which allowed the researchers to gather a wide variety of information and hear the nuance behind it.
Of course, 82 participants across nine sites is a small sample, so the findings should be seen as qualitative and exploratory rather than nationally representative. Still, the responses identify some consistent patterns and offer some potential solutions.
People don’t know how bad things are
The authors deliberately focused on communities where academic proficiency scores were low, in the bottom fifth of all schools statewide. Yet more than half of the participants weren’t familiar with how their local schools actually performed.
Schools Need to Adopt Clear Rules for AI Use. Parents Can Help Make That Happen
Focus group participants reported that they rarely heard news about student reading and math scores. Instead, they described district communications as occasionally misleading. For example, one expressed concern that the local district was celebrating growth metrics that obscured persistently low performance. As another participant put it: “Parents can’t be involved if they aren’t informed. They can’t be informed if they aren’t invited.”
Those who do know the ratings think their schools are failing
Among respondents familiar with the performance data, more than half rated their local district schools as needing improvement, or worse. When asked about the quality of different types of schools in their communities, participants gave district schools the lowest average rating, below charter and private schools and vocational programs. They described teachers ill-prepared for diverse classrooms, inadequate special education services and a striking absence of practical preparation for students in things like financial literacy or vocational and technical skills.
Communities want to help but feel shut out
A majority of participants said they want to be real partners in improving their schools, but fewer than a quarter said they think their districts actually want that. School boards, in particular, were rated as particularly unreceptive to community input.
By Communicating Better With Families, Our North Carolina District Builds Trust
The anecdotes reveal a repeating pattern: People show up to meetings, join committees, raise concerns — and are ignored, dismissed or labeled as troublemakers. In some communities, language barriers and unreliable translation services make things harder. In others, parents hold back out of fear that speaking up could affect how their children are treated in school. Overall, only about a quarter said they felt they could personally drive change.
And yet, people are still willing to get involved. Nearly 90% of participants said they would join a community task force to improve their local schools. More than half said they’d take on an active or leadership role, and nearly two-thirds were optimistic about what a coordinated community group could accomplish. People may not think they can drive change on their own, but they still hold out hope for collective improvement efforts.
So what would actually help?
Participants had concrete suggestions like flexible meeting times, reliable translation services, transportation, modest stipends to recognize parents’ time commitments and protections against retaliation. Procedurally, they wanted to feel like they are being included early, not handed decisions after they have already been made.
Lessons Learned from 20-Plus Years of Public School Parent Advocacy
None of this will be especially surprising to people who’ve followed education debates over the years. This is not the first report to find that families are often excluded from decision-making.
Still, the Hoover research adds nuance and urgency. It offers a portrait of communities that are ready and willing to be involved, but are often blocked from doing so — and provides a set of suggestions for what changing that would take.
Did you use this article in your work?
We’d love to hear how The 74’s reporting is helping educators, researchers, and policymakers. Tell us how
