For most families, the college search process starts backwards — students chase dream schools, rankings, and peer pressure, and only after acceptance letters arrive does the real question hit: “How are we actually going to pay for this?”
That’s exactly why College Aid Pro’s Matt Carpenter sat down with college admissions and financial aid expert JP Schmidt on our podcast, Ol’ College Try. JP spent decades inside higher education — including time as a financial aid director at the University of Southern California — and today works directly with families to help them navigate admissions, financial aid, and affordability with a clear-eyed understanding of how colleges really operate.
“Families are playing checkers while colleges are playing chess.”
— JP Schmidt, College Admissions & Financial Aid Expert
The College Planning Process Most Families Get Wrong
JP described a pattern he sees over and over: families shop for colleges, emotionally attach to those schools, and then scramble to figure out the finances afterward. The problem? Once a student falls in love with a school, practical financial decisions become nearly impossible. Parents often stretch beyond their comfort zone because they don’t want to disappoint their child after an acceptance letter arrives.
His prescription: reverse the process entirely. Start by understanding what type of college experience actually fits the student academically, socially, and financially — before falling in love with any school’s name or ranking.
💡 Key Insight: Colleges understand enrollment strategy, tuition pricing, and financial aid packaging at a level most families never encounter. Without a plan, you can easily overpay simply because you didn’t understand how the system works.
Why Rankings Often Distract Families From What Matters Most
One of JP’s strongest points: families confuse prestige with fit. Parents naturally want the “best” school — but “best” is usually defined by rankings or brand recognition rather than whether that school is the right environment for their specific child.
JP also pointed out that rankings themselves are heavily manipulated. Colleges strategically manage admissions data, pricing, and selectivity metrics because rankings drive perception and application volume. The correlation between a school’s ranking and its ability to help a specific student succeed is much weaker than most families assume.
Better question to ask: Not “what school sounds most impressive?” but “where is my student most likely to thrive?” — based on their learning style, goals, personality, and support needs.
College Affordability Has Changed Dramatically
JP reflected on his own experience attending Iowa State University and how different the financial realities were compared to today. When he was in school, students could recover from financial missteps without life-altering consequences — costs were lower and manageable borrowing was realistic.
Today, the stakes are much higher. That’s why JP strongly believes families must establish a realistic college budget before students begin building a school list. Those financial conversations can feel uncomfortable, but avoiding them leads to much larger problems later.
He explained that college affordability typically comes from one of three places:
Affordability Source
What It Means
Fair Sticker Price
The college’s published cost is already reasonable for your family from the start
Merit Scholarships
Schools use merit aid to attract strong students, regardless of financial need
Need-Based Aid
For many families, this is the biggest factor — but requires qualifying and applying
CAP’s rule of thumb: Understand which schools align with your family’s financial situation before applications are submitted — not after you’re already emotionally invested in an acceptance.
The Truth About Colleges That “Meet 100% of Need”
Families often hear this phrase during the admissions process and assume it guarantees an affordable offer. JP offered an important reality check: colleges still have significant control over how they calculate that need. Schools may weigh income, assets, home equity, or other factors differently based on their own institutional methodology.
As a result, two families with nearly identical financial situations can receive very different aid packages from the same school.
Important: Financial aid offices operate within budgets, enrollment goals, and institutional priorities. While many counselors genuinely want to help, colleges are businesses that must manage revenue strategically. A financial aid package is not entirely objective or standardized — understanding this helps families make smarter decisions.
How Students Should Actually Build Their College List
JP encourages families to think about college fit in three layers — and to tackle them in order:
Layer 1
Academic Fit
Does this school actually support the student’s interests, intended major, and preferred learning style? Many students get emotionally attached before confirming the college even offers the programs they want. JP also emphasizes that learning environment matters — some students thrive in large lecture halls, others need collaborative or project-based settings.
Layer 2
Financial Fit
Once schools make academic sense, evaluate them through the lens of your family’s budget. Students should absolutely have exciting options — but only within financial guardrails that protect both the student and parents from unsustainable debt.
Layer 3
Personal Fit
Campus culture, social life, geography, traditions, and community all matter — and this is where students should have real ownership. Once academic and financial realities are clear, students can confidently choose the environment where they feel they belong.
The Bigger Goal Beyond College Admissions
One of the most memorable moments in the episode came when JP compared college planning to planning a wedding. The wedding itself is not the ultimate goal — the life built afterward is what truly matters. A college acceptance letter is not the finish line. It’s one step toward building a successful adult life.
When families focus only on prestige or admissions outcomes, they can lose sight of what actually matters: financial flexibility, career opportunities, graduate school options, and long-term financial wellness.
“The best college is not the most prestigious one. It’s the school where a student can thrive academically, graduate with manageable debt, and build a strong future afterward.”
— JP Schmidt
Ready to Build a Smarter College List?
Create a free MyCap account and start building a college list that fits your student academically, personally, and financially.
Create Your Free MyCap Account →
Click Here to listen to the Full Episode!
